Today we’ll dive into my thoughts on Umberto Eco’s masterpiece novel The Name of the Rose.
I’m honestly a bit shocked at how resistant I’ve been to this book the whole year. I knew it would be “hard,” so I kept putting it off. But I love Infinite Jest and Gravity’s Rainbow and a bunch of hard books.
This book has a reputation it doesn’t deserve.
I didn’t think it was hard at all in the same way those other ones are. It’s actually written in a very similar way to the way I write.
There are so many interesting layers to this book that it will be hard to discuss the “mystery novel” aspect because that was only one piece (and kind of the least interesting).
Early on, we get one of my favorite characters. He can’t speak any known language, but he’s lived in so many places that he’s developed his own. It takes from all the common languages and merges into a strange thing anyone can understand.
Eco doesn’t do this in the abstract, either; the speech is written out fully.
This character is a synecdoche for the book itself. The Name of the Rose isn’t a historical work or pure fiction or a mystery novel or postmodernist metafiction or theology.
It draws on a bunch of sources and amalgamates them to a strange hybrid a reader from any of these backgrounds could appreciate on a different level.
Eco doesn’t hide the pieces. They are all in plain sight through the characters. We have Jorge de Burgos representing Jorge Luis Borges. We get William of Baskerville representing Sherlock Holmes. And the title itself is obviously a reference to Romeo and Juliet.
…Or is it?
Eco actually tells us the true inspiration is a Latin verse by a Benedictine monk named Bernard of Cluny. Since Eco was a semiotician, I have to believe he also had Wittgenstein in the back of his head, too.
The narrator travels to a monastery, and upon arrival, there is a mysterious death of one of the monks. He appears to have thrown himself from the window of a library.
Over the next few days, many more deaths occur.
This occupies the main narrative momentum, but I basically want to not discuss this further. Anyone who reads this book for the mystery is in for a shock. Let’s get back to the references.
Everyone sees some of the obvious Borges references from his famous stories. But if you’ve read Labyrinths, you might start to think every single story in the collection gets referenced.
I think I’ve made my point. It’s not just “The Library of Babel,” like many people believe. It’s almost a transformation of the themes of the full collection of stories into a novel.
Another fascinating, easy to overlook aspect of the book, is the chapter summary at the start of each chapter. At first, I thought they were mere summaries. But they got long and weird and pretty humorous as they went on.
Most people probably skip them thinking they offer nothing but a summary. Here’s one:
In which, though the chapter is short, old Alinardo says very interesting things about the labyrinth and about the way to enter it.
It doesn’t say much, but it teaches you something important: these summaries will provide commentary in addition to the summary. Here’s another:
In which the labyrinth is finally broached, and the intruders have strange visions and, as happens in labyrinths, lose their way.
If these were just summaries it shouldn’t provide commentary on the length of the chapter or how “interesting” a certain conversation is or remark “as happens in labyrinths.”
I grew to love these summaries as much as the chapters themselves.
I’m not sure what else to say. I’m excited to re-read this. I think it will be as exciting as the first time through as I catch more and more references and understand the themes better.
I must caution that this is absolutely not for everyone, but if you find any of this post interesting, I can’t recommend this book enough. It is brilliant and well-deserved of the praise it has received over the years.
I even got a copy of Eco’s Foucault’s Pendulum to read soon.
Anecdotally, the reading of literature seems to be down in these trying times. I’ve spoken…
Finding that perfect balance for characterization can be difficult. Many err on the side of…
John Milton is known as one of the greatest English language poets of all time.…
It's that time of the year again. Halloween is around the corner, and horror films…
I'm often caught reading strange books that no one has heard of. Family members ask…
Persuasive essays are one of the few skills that transfer to the real world. It's…